paradox stress

The Paradox of Stress: Understanding Hans Selye’s Enduring Observation

Paradox – stress

Stress research has been around for more than 80-90 years.

In the 1930s, Hans Selye introduced the term ‘stress’ soon after his 1936 Nature magazine publication entitled “A syndrome produced by diverse nocuous agents”. Often this Nature study is linked to the birth of the stress concept, but in this article the expression ‘stress’, was substituted with ‘alarm reaction’, due to an editorial suggestion.

According to Gerald Weissmann, the Editor-in-Chief of the FASEB journal (2006 – 2016), in the 1940s and 1950s Selye began to promote ‘stress’ as “the major cause, mode of transmission and treatment of most human ills, be they mental or physical.” As per Weissmann, Hans Selye pursued two careers – experimental pathology and public relations, and he was a success at both.

Time magazine Cover 1983By the 1950s, stress was linked to herpes, whooping cough, cancer and the common cold. This also includes high blood pressure, peptic ulcers and coronary thrombosis (New Scientist, 12 Nov. 1959). And Time magazine’s June 6, 1983 cover story called stress “The Epidemic of the Eighties”.

In 2007, Weissmann wrote the day after Paris Hilton was released from the Los Angeles County jail that she confessed to Larry King on CNN that “I’ve been through a lot and it was a pretty traumatic experience.” Furthermore, quote: “Even before Ms. Hilton was jailed for violating a court order, she had stopped eating “under the stress” of her impending stay in the hoosegow”. It’s no wonder that ‘stress’ has been tossed into the word-salad of psychobabble with such other ingredients as ‘anger-management’, ‘self-esteem’, ‘insecurity’, and ‘closure’.

But as per Weissmann, stress is a ‘top banana’. Thus, according to the American Institute of Stress, stress is America’s #1 health problem. Moreover, in the 1990s the World Health Organization called the stress of everyday life “a worldwide epidemic.”

BrainImmune: Trends in Neuroendocrine Immunology is the first online resource covering stress-immune interactions, the interface of stress and immunity and the impact of stress on health and disease – an often overlooked and not quite understood area.

We feature over 100 articles in this field, with more than 25 articles related to stress and cancer.

But we have always wondered why, according to Selye stress is “too well known and too little understood” and why this is even more relevant today?

To discover the answer to this enigmatic question, we decided to use an Artificial Intelligence (AI). We selected the AI product “Gemini Advanced” from Google DeepMind and set it to “Deep Research” mode, then we gave it the prompt provided below. Google DeepMind is a subsidiary of Alphabet Inc.

Our prompt for “Gemini Advanced”:


The father of the ‘stress’ (psychological stress) concept and theory – Hans Selye, who started and developed this medical research field, said, quote:

Stress like relativity is a scientific concept, which has suffered from the mixed blessing of being too well known and too little understood.

1. Why did Selye say that?
2. What did he have in mind?
3. When (which year) was that said?
4. Who in fact was Hans Selye?
5. Why the field of stress research was very popular in the 1950s, 1960s, 1970s and 1980s but not nowadays when medical research is dominated by an approach known as reductionism.


We were pleased by the quality and structure of the response Gemini Advanced gave us and are including it here verbatim.

The Paradox of Stress: Understanding Hans Selye’s Enduring Observation

Hans Selye, a Hungarian-Canadian endocrinologist, is widely recognized as the father of the concept of psychological stress in the field of medical research 1. His pioneering work laid the foundation for our understanding of how organisms respond to stressors, significantly impacting various scientific disciplines from endocrinology to psychology 1. Towards the end of his distinguished career, in 1980, Selye made a profound statement about the very concept he had brought to prominence: “Stress like relativity is a scientific concept, which has suffered from the mixed blessing of being too well known and too little understood” 8. This observation encapsulates a central paradox surrounding the concept of stress, one that this report will explore by delving into the reasons behind Selye’s statement, his intended meaning, the context of his remark, his biography, and the historical trajectory of stress research in relation to the contemporary dominance of reductionism in medicine.

Deconstructing Selye’s Observation: “Too Well Known, Too Little Understood”

“Too Well Known”: The Popularization of the Term “Stress”

Hans Selye introduced the term ‘stress’ into the medical vocabulary in the 1930s, shortly after his initial publication in Nature in 1936 2. His subsequent research and numerous publications, including the influential books “The Stress of Life” (1956) and “Stress Without Distress” (1974), played a pivotal role in popularizing the concept 2. Selye’s work resonated deeply with the experiences of individuals in modern society, characterized by increasing demands and pressures 9. The term ‘stress’ quickly permeated everyday language, becoming a common descriptor for feelings of pressure, anxiety, and being overwhelmed 10. By the later part of his career, Selye himself noted that ‘stress’ had become almost a household term 19. This widespread adoption, while indicative of the concept’s perceived relevance, might have inadvertently led to a superficial understanding of its complex nature.

“Too Little Understood”: The Depth and Nuances of Selye’s Stress Concept

At the heart of Selye’s contribution lies his General Adaptation Syndrome (GAS), a model describing the body’s three-stage response to prolonged stressors: alarm, resistance, and exhaustion 2. This response is notably non-specific, meaning the body reacts in a similar physiological manner to a wide variety of stressors 1. A crucial element of this response, extensively studied by Selye, is the role of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis, a neuroendocrine system that mediates the body’s reaction to stress 2.

Furthermore, Selye distinguished between eustress, or positive stress, which can be beneficial and motivating, and distress, or negative stress, which can be harmful 3. He also introduced the concept of “adaptation energy,” suggesting that the body has a finite capacity to adapt to prolonged stress, with depletion leading to the stage of exhaustion 5. These intricate physiological mechanisms and nuanced distinctions within Selye’s stress concept often go unappreciated in the general understanding of the term, contributing to the “too little understood” aspect of his observation.

The Analogy with Relativity

Selye’s comparison of stress to relativity underscores his belief that both are fundamental scientific concepts that have entered public discourse but are frequently understood only at a superficial level 8. Just as the general public might have a basic understanding of Einstein’s theory of relativity involving time and space, their grasp of stress might be limited to the feeling of being under pressure, without a deeper comprehension of the underlying biological processes and potential long-term health consequences. Both concepts, in their complete scientific form, demand a level of detailed study and understanding that typically exceeds popular knowledge. The analogy highlights Selye’s concern that the widespread use of the term ‘stress’ might mask a lack of genuine understanding of its complexities and implications for health and disease.

Hans Selye: The Life and Work of a Pioneer

Early Life and Education

János Hugo Bruno “Hans” Selye was born in Vienna, Austria, in 1907, into a family with Hungarian roots 1. Raised in a multilingual environment, he developed a strong sense of his Hungarian heritage 1. His medical education at the German University of Prague proved to be a pivotal experience, as his early observations of patients exhibiting a common “syndrome of just being sick,” regardless of their specific diagnoses, ignited his lifelong interest in the body’s non-specific responses to illness 1. He furthered his academic pursuits by obtaining a PhD in organic chemistry and undertaking research fellowships at Johns Hopkins University and McGill University in Montreal 1. These early experiences and his diverse educational background laid the groundwork for his groundbreaking contributions to stress research.

The Development of Stress Theory

Selye’s development of stress theory was significantly influenced by his serendipitous findings during experiments with rats at McGill University. Initially focused on sex hormones, he observed that rats exposed to various noxious agents, such as cold, surgical injury, and drugs, consistently displayed a common set of physiological responses, including adrenal enlargement, thymic and lymph node atrophy, and gastric ulcers 1.

Hans Selye stressFigure 1. The hypothalamus-hypophysis-adrenal-thymus axis. Although Selye made many contributions to biology and medicine, he considered the discovery of this axis the most significant.

This led him to formulate the concept of the General Adaptation Syndrome (GAS), outlining the three stages of the body’s response to stress: the initial alarm reaction, followed by the stage of resistance where the body adapts, and finally, the stage of exhaustion if the stressor persists 2. To clarify the distinction between the external cause and the internal response, Selye introduced the term ‘stressor’ 19. His research also elucidated the crucial role of the HPA axis and the release of glucocorticoids in mediating these stress responses 2.

Major Publications and Impact

Selye’s ideas gained widespread recognition through his extensive publications. His 1936 article in Nature, titled “A Syndrome Produced by Diverse Nocuous Agents,” marked the formal introduction of his stress concept to the scientific community 2. Subsequent books, notably “The Stress of Life” (1956) and “Stress Without Distress” (1974), brought his theories to a broader audience, achieving international bestseller status 2.

Selye’s work had a profound impact across various scientific and medical fields, including endocrinology, psychology, and medicine, revolutionizing the understanding of disease and adaptation 1. He further solidified his legacy by founding the International Institute of Stress in 1975 and the Hans Selye Foundation in 1979 2. His significant contributions were acknowledged through numerous honors and awards, including multiple nominations for the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 1.

The Golden Age of Stress Research (1950s-1980s)

Factors Contributing to Popularity

The period between the 1950s and 1980s witnessed a surge in the popularity of stress research, driven by a confluence of scientific and societal factors. The post-World War II era saw an increased awareness of anxiety and mental health issues, contributing to a greater interest in understanding the impact of psychological factors on well-being 30. The rise of psychosomatic medicine, which explored the intricate connections between the mind and body, further fueled the interest in stress research 5.

Hans Selye’s extensive body of work and his ability to communicate complex scientific ideas to a broad audience played a crucial role in this popularization 5. The medicalization of anxiety during this time, leading to the development and marketing of anxiolytic drugs, also highlighted the perceived link between psychological distress and physiological health 30. Moreover, there was a growing recognition of occupational stress as a significant and widespread phenomenon affecting individuals in various workplaces 34. By the late 1970s and early 1980s, the term “stress” had become firmly entrenched in popular vernacular, reflecting its perceived relevance to the human condition 18.

Key Research Areas and Findings

During this period, stress research encompassed a wide range of investigations. Significant attention was paid to understanding the physiological effects of stress on various bodily systems, including the cardiovascular, immune, and endocrine systems 9. Studies explored the links between chronic stress and the development of various diseases, such as ulcers, hypertension, and heart attacks 2. The development of stress management techniques and interventions also became a prominent area of research, aiming to mitigate the negative effects of stress on health and well-being 22. Furthermore, psychological perspectives on stress began to emerge, focusing on cognitive processes such as appraisal and coping mechanisms that influence an individual’s response to stressors 12.

The Rise of Reductionism in Modern Medical Research

Defining Reductionism

Reductionism is a philosophical approach in science that posits that complex systems can be understood by breaking them down into their simpler, more fundamental components 47. In biological science, ontological reductionism suggests that biological systems are ultimately composed of molecules and their interactions 48. Methodological reductionism advocates for investigating biological systems at the lowest possible level to gain the most fruitful insights, while epistemic reductionism proposes that knowledge of higher-level domains can always be reduced to a more fundamental level 48. The historical roots of reductionism can be traced back to ancient philosophers like Thales and were later revived by figures such as René Descartes, who likened the world to a clockwork mechanism that could be understood by examining its individual parts 48.

The Ascendancy of Molecular Biology and Genetics

The latter half of the 20th century witnessed a significant rise in the fields of molecular biology and genetics, which further propelled the reductionist approach in medical research 49. Advancements in these areas have enabled researchers to focus on identifying specific genes, molecules, and cellular pathways involved in the development and progression of diseases 48. This reductionist focus has led to the development of highly targeted therapies aimed at specific molecular abnormalities, offering the promise of more effective and less toxic treatments for various conditions 48. The success of these approaches in treating diseases at a molecular level has solidified the dominance of reductionism in contemporary medical research.

Why Reductionism Might Seem to Overshadow Holistic Approaches like Stress Research

The prevailing focus on specific molecular mechanisms within reductionism presents a contrast to Selye’s broader, non-specific definition of stress as the body’s response to any demand 1. Studying a systemic and multi-factorial phenomenon like stress through a purely reductionist lens poses significant challenges, as it involves complex interactions across multiple biological and psychological levels 20. Critics of reductionism point out its potential limitations, including oversimplification of complex processes, the difficulty in definitively separating cause and effect, and the risk of overlooking the individual patient’s unique experience 48. In contrast to this approach, holistic perspectives emphasize the importance of considering the organism as a whole, recognizing that biological systems often exhibit emergent properties that cannot be predicted by examining their individual components in isolation 1. The current emphasis on reductionism in medical research might therefore appear to overshadow more holistic approaches like Selye’s initial conceptualization of stress, which focused on the body’s overall adaptive response rather than specific molecular targets.

The Enduring Legacy and Current Relevance of Stress Research

Continued Research in the Age of Reductionism

Despite the dominance of reductionism, stress research continues to be a significant and actively pursued field of study 2. Contemporary research delves into various aspects of stress, including the long-term impact of chronic stress on physical and mental health, the intricate role of stress in the development and progression of mental health disorders such as anxiety and depression, and the development of effective interventions for stress management 39. There is also ongoing investigation into the complex interplay between psychological stress, the immune system, and susceptibility to various diseases 8. These continued efforts highlight the enduring recognition of stress as a critical factor influencing human health and well-being, even within the framework of modern reductionist-leaning medical science.

The Value of a Holistic Perspective

While reductionist approaches offer valuable insights into the molecular mechanisms underlying disease, a holistic understanding of stress, as initially advocated by Selye, remains crucial for addressing the complex health challenges of today 1. An integrated approach that combines the strengths of both reductionist and holistic perspectives may provide a more comprehensive understanding of stress and its multifaceted impact on health 50. Recognizing the importance of psychological, social, and environmental factors, in addition to biological mechanisms, is essential for developing effective strategies to prevent and manage stress-related health problems 6.

Conclusion: Selye’s Enduring Wisdom

In conclusion, Hans Selye’s observation that stress is “too well known and too little understood” in 1980 remains remarkably pertinent today. While the term ‘stress’ has become ubiquitous in our vocabulary, the profound physiological and psychological complexities elucidated by Selye and subsequent research are often not fully appreciated. His pioneering work on the General Adaptation Syndrome and the body’s non-specific response to stressors laid a foundational cornerstone in medical science. Although modern medical research is largely dominated by a reductionist approach that focuses on specific molecular mechanisms, the enduring relevance of stress as a major determinant of health necessitates a continued and deeper understanding of its holistic impact. Integrating the precision of reductionist science with the comprehensive perspective of holistic approaches, as Selye initially envisioned, holds the key to unlocking more effective strategies for promoting health and well-being in the face of the ever-present challenges of stress in modern life.


Professional AI assistance:

The production of this article was assisted by an Artificial Intelligence (AI). Zlatin Balevsky helped formulate the instructions given to the AI. Balevsky Research Services LTD offers consulting services to scientists interested in leveraging AI in their research.


References:

  1. Hans Selye (1907–1982): Founder of the stress theory – PMC – PubMed Central
  2. Hans Selye, MD PhD – Canadian Medical Hall of Fame
  3. Hans Selye – Wikipedia
  4. Hans Selye (1907–1982) – Canada.ca
  5. Evaluating the Role of Hans Selye in the Modern History of Stress – NCBI
  6. Hans Selye | The Canadian Encyclopedia
  7. Hans Selye | Stress Physiology, Adaptation & Hormones – Britannica
  8. Hans Selye Famous Quotes – BrainImmune
  9. The Stressed World And Hans Selye – BrainImmune
  10. The origins of the word stress | UKEssays.com
  11. International Journal of Multidisciplinary Educational Research – Amazon S3
  12. To Assess the Stress Sources and Coping Behaviour among the Football Players – IJIP
  13. (PDF) Portraying Indonesian Children’s Well-Being with the Multidimensional Student Life Satisfaction Scale: A Preliminary Study – ResearchGate
  14. Editorial: Stress in health and disease: new era and new challenges – Frontiers
  15. Hans Selye: “Complete freedom from stress is death” – Strategy and Rest
  16. Selye Stress Response – YouTube
  17. Dr. Joe Schwarcz on Dr. Hans Selye and stress – YouTube
  18. Stress, Coping, and Health – Sage Publishing
  19. Full article: The legacy of Hans Selye and the origins of stress research: A retrospective 75 years after his landmark brief “Letter” to the Editor# of Nature – Taylor and Francis
  20. Studying Stress | Introduction to Psychology – Lumen Learning
  21. Hans Selye: The Discovery Of Stress – BrainHQ
  22. Stress Management 2.0 – A Holistic Approach to Self-management Online – DiVA portal
  23. Theories of Stress and Its Relationship to Health – Sage Publishing
  24. The Phases of Stress Disorder and the Discovery of Nobel Laureate, Hans Selye – Dr. Andrew Neville
  25. Remembering Hans Seyle – The Pathologist
  26. Meet the Scientist Hans Selye – YouTube
  27. Dr. Hans Selye – YouTube
  28. Hans Selye – Concordia University
  29. Hans Seyle education – Google
  30. How an Age of Anxiety Became an Age of Depression – PMC – PubMed Central
  31. Studies show normal children today report more anxiety than child psychiatric patients in the 1950’s
  32. The Age of Anxiety? Birth Cohort Change in Anxiety and Neuroticism, 1952-1993 – American Psychological Association
  33. Medicalization of Stress | Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Psychology
  34. Heart Disease and the Stress Hypothesis in the Mid-twentieth Century – BMC blog network
  35. An Investigation into the Medicalization of Stress in the Twentieth Century – ResearchGate
  36. Let’s Talk about Stress: History of Stress Research – Alexandra M. Robinson, 2018
  37. Medicalization of Stress | Oxford Research Encyclopedia of …
  38. LABOURING STRESS: SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH, TRADE UNIONS AND PERCEPTIONS OF WORKPLACE STRESS IN MID-TWENTIETH-CENTURY BRITAIN – NCBI
  39. Stress statistics 2024: How common is stress, and who’s most affected? – SingleCare
  40. STRESS RESEARCH – The American Institute of Stress
  41. Current Research Projects | Stress Health Center – Stanford Medicine
  42. Research < Yale Stress Center
  43. Current Stress Research – ISMA
  44. Stress News – ScienceDaily
  45. The Effects of Holistic Modalities on Stress Reduction in Nursing Students Attending School during the Pandemic – ScholarWorks at WMU
  46. Exploring the sustained impact of the Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction program: a thematic analysis – Frontiers
  47. Medical reductionism: Lessons from the great philosophers – ResearchGate
  48. Medical reductionism: lessons from the great philosophers | QJM: An …
  49. Medical reductionism: lessons from the great philosophers | QJM – Oxford Academic
  50. Reductionistic and Holistic Science – PMC – PubMed Central
  51. The Limits of Reductionism in Medicine: Could Systems Biology Offer an Alternative? – PMC
  52. Reductionism and complexity in molecular biology: Scientists now have the tools to unravel biological complexity and overcome the limitations of reductionism – EMBO Press
  53. Quantitative medicine: Tracing the transition from holistic to reductionist approaches. A new “quantitative holism” is possible? – Luca Saba, Silvano Tagliagambe, 2023 – Sage Journals
  54. Medical reductionism: Lessons from the great philosophers – ResearchGate
  55. Holism and Reductionism -A-Level Psycholog – Study Mind
  56. A criticism of the reductionist and holistic vision in the planning of drugs in biological, chemical and physical level – Redalyc
  57. Reductionism Vs Holism – CGS Psychology Blog: Mrs Harris
  58. Reductionism in medical science and practice | QJM: An International Journal of Medicine
  59. The history of reductionism versus holistic approaches to scientific research – ResearchGate
  60. Reductionism and Holism: Definition, Difference | StudySmarter
  61. The pursuit of happiness: The social and scientific origins of Hans Selye’s natural philosophy of life – PubMed Central
  62. A criticism of the reductionist and holistic vision in the planning of drugs in biological, chemical and physical level – Redalyc
  63. Stress in America™ 2020 A National Mental Health Crisis – American Psychological Association
  64. Stress in America™ 2020: A National Mental Health Crisis
  65. Stress in America 2023: A nation recovering from collective trauma
  66. Stress: statistics | Mental Health Foundation
  67. People experiencing stress, depression, and anxiety symptoms by age group worldwide 2022 | Statista
  68. The Global Prevalence of Depression, Anxiety, Stress, and Insomnia Among General Population During COVID-19 Pandemic: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis – PMC
  69. American Adults Express Increasing Anxiousness in Annual Poll; Stress and Sleep are Key Factors Impacting Mental Health

Related stories you may like:

Hans Selye and the Birth of the Stress Concept

Selye and the 80th Birthday of Stress Research

Hans Selye and Paris Hilton: Gerald Weissmann’s Thoughts about the Experimental Pathology of Stress

The Stressed World and Hans Selye

Hans Selye Famous Quotes

Bridging Neurosciences and Immunology – An Overview