One of the paradoxes of medical sciences is building boundaries between disciplines and drawing dividing lines between research fields.
Moreover, medical research, whose major objective is to find out the basis of human diseases, is quite often governed by reductionism. Thus, “medicine is following a philosophy of ‘reductionism’: deconstructing a complex process into its component parts to enable better comprehension”.
We believe that in contemporary medical research:
Reductionism remains a popular approach and mindset; and particularly immunology, a major research field, is dominated by cell-centric reductionism.
Also, there is a ‘cultural divide’ between neuroscience and immunology – the two largest medical research areas.
The role of ‘systemic’ factors such as the neuroendocrine-immune dysfunction, and the role of stress and stress-immune interactions is often overlooked and is a poorly understood area.
The concepts discussed at BrainImmune represent recent advances in the field; they are not available in medical textbooks, and, as a general rule, not taught at medical schools, or PhD training or programs, particularly in the immunology world.
We believe that
the neuroendocrine-immune dysfunction and abnormal stress-immune interactions represent major components essential to all common complex human diseases.
Some examples from BrainImmune are presented below:
This formed the basis for the fetal programming of asthma hypothesis, which proposes that stress experienced during pregnancy may lead to vulnerability of the immune system towards atopic diseases and asthma.
In childhood, multiple mechanisms affect the stress response, which in turn influences the manifestations of asthma in children. Moreover, we provide some historical perspectives of the Andor Szentivanyi and the beta adrenergic theory of allergy and asthma. According to Szentivanyi, “… abnormality in asthma lies in the reduced functioning … of the beta adrenergic system …,”. The beta adrenergic theory regards asthma not as an ‘immunological disease’, but as a unique pattern of bronchial hypersensitivity to a broad spectrum of immunological, psychic, infectious, chemical and physical stimuli.
Autoimmunity and Rheumatic Diseases
We feature over 25 articles in this area. For instance, this includes:
We present the attractive new concept on stress-induced Th2 shift driving thyroid autoimmunity, which is in favor of the clinical data that stress hormones influence the clinical expression of thyroid autoimmunity towards the development of Graves’ disease (GD).
We also outline the role of several hormones in the pathogenesis and/or treatment of rheumatoid arthritis (RA).
Edith Piaf, the famed French singer, also had severe RA; Edith Piaf became addicted to painkillers she took for rheumatoid arthritis. Indeed, one of her famous songs was “Non, je ne regrette rien”. That philosophy could have applied to her approach to living with RA.
This includes:
The discovery of cortisone more than seventy years ago. September 21, 1948 marked the beginning of a new era of medicine, when the first patient with rheumatoid arthritis was injected with cortisone.
A Canadian research group discussed the evidence for a dysfunctional sympathetic-immune interface in disease states of the Gastrointestinal (GI) tract. During the early stages of inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) the sympathetic nervous system may enhance inflammation by increasing immune cell infiltration and promoting antigen presentation. In contrast, during established GI inflammation, catecholamine-induced inhibition of TNF-α secretion and increased production of Th2 cytokines may limit the inflammatory response.
The vicious circular pathway between nociceptive neurons and Th17 immune responses in psoriatic lesions. Neuropeptides (CGRP, SP, VIP) prompt the release of IL-6 and IL-23 and bias antigen presentation for Th17 cell responses. Neuropeptides also prompt Th cells to release IL-17, IL-31, and IL-33. Increased cytokines can sensitize TRPV1 and TRPA1 channels through GPCRs via secondary messenger-signaling pathways, the cAMP/PKA and PLC/PKC pathways, following Ca2+ elevation. From ‘The Role of Nociceptive Neurons in the Pathogenesis of Psoriasis’ in Front. Immunol., 29 September 2020. Public Domain.
In this model, a subset of sensory neurons expressing the ion channels TRPV1 and Nav1.8 play a major role in triggering IL-23 production by nearby DDCs. Thus, IL-23 in turn may act on skin-resident T cells to induce IL-17 and IL-22, and precipitate the recruitment of neutrophils and monocytes that drive psoriasis-like skin inflammation. By 2020, it became clear that the neurogenic inflammation, induced by nociceptive neurons and Th17 responses, has a fundamental role in psoriasis.
Lidocaine is a non-selective blocker to voltage-gated sodium channels, and new research indicates that lidocaine acting on sensory neurons can down-regulate disordered neurite growth and pro-inflammatory CGRP release. Briefly, lidocaine improves psoriasis via inhibition of CGRP-induced IL-23 production. Thus, modulating the neuro-immune cross-talk may turn out to be a new approach to control neurogenic inflammation.
Cardiovascular Diseases
Stress and Cardiovascular Diseases
We review new evidence and understanding that links stress, proinflammation and cardiovascular diseases. Chronic stress can enhance and maintain a proinflammatory state, which plays an important role in the pathogenesis of cardiovascular diseases, making the phenomenon of proinflammation central in this new concept.
In fact, stress may start driving cardiovascular and metabolic risk early in life. The 1958 British Birth Cohort Study is perhaps the first to suggest that “increased risk of cardiometabolic disease associated with distress in childhood may be maintained even if distress remits by adulthood”.
In addition, new evidence links myocardial inflammation to the pathophysiology behind stress-induced cardiomyopathy, also known as “Takotsubo” cardiomyopathy. Thus, stress-induced inflammation, and particularly catecholamine-induced inflammation, might represent the driving force leading to the development of acute symptoms and transiently altered ventricular contractility.
A recent study indicates that a higher resting heart rate (RHR) is linked to low natural killer cell activity (NKA). Reduced NKA is associated with an increased susceptibility to infections and increased risk of cancer. This suggests the usefulness of RHR, a simple indicator reflecting increased sympathetic nervous system activity, in predicting reduced immune function or NK cell activity.
The mechanisms are not well-understood, however, although chronic low-grade inflammation is thought to play a role based on studies of patients with depression, anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorder. While hsCRP is a nonspecific marker in and of itself, it is an easy way to detect low levels of inflammation.
One of the paradigm shifts in our understanding about atherosclerosis is the development of the concept that it is potentially caused by a chronic inflammation. Serum interleukin-6 (IL-6) – as a significant predictor of future cardiovascular (CV) events, is discussed in several studies; and here, importantly – why serum IL-6, but not CRP may be a significant predictor of CV events.
Cancer
We feature more than 25 articles in this area. Here we discuss a Science magazine study revealing that the autonomic nerves contribute to prostate cancer growth. Namely, the sympathetic nervous system via the β2- and β3-adrenergic receptor pathways participate in the early phase of tumor development.
We also discuss a Nature magazine study disclosing an impaired neuro-endocrine microenvironment of the bone marrow, and particularly that the sympathetic neuropathy plays a crucial role in the development of myeloproliferative neoplasms (MPNs). The study reports that the sympathetic nerve fibers and the supporting Schwann cells are reduced in the bone marrow of MPN patients.
The Role of Stress and the Sympathetic Nervous System
A recent study reveals that stress and epinephrine promote leukemia progression. Another study, discussed in this report, indicates that stress can enhance the progression of human pre-B cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia in an orthotopic mouse model.
Another study identifies sympathetic nervous system (SNS) activation as a novel physiologic regulator of breast cancer metastasis. The authors demonstrate that physical restraint, applied as a standardized stressor increased the metastasis of primary breast tumor cells to distant tissues by 38-fold, and stress increased metastasis in clinically relevant tissues, with a 37-fold increase in the lung and a 67% increase in the lymph nodes.
Another study showing that stress hormones i.e. epinephrine (adrenaline) may promote the transformation of M1-type macrophages to M2-type macrophages and, thus, accelerate tumor growth in a mouse model of breast cancer. Thus, stress may promote breast cancer progression through macrophages M2 polarization in tumor microenvironment.
These newly identified immature myeloid cells are characterized by the ability to suppress immune responses and expand during cancer, infection, and inflammatory diseases. Of note, when study participants were evaluated for objective, longer-term stressors’ effect, patients with higher stress levels exhibited higher baseline numbers of MDSC.
Another study discussed by us in this report, indicates that the pre-exposure of chronic stress contributes to MDSCs elevation and facilitated breast cancer metastasis in tumor-bearing mice. Taken together, these data indicated that chronic stress may accumulate MDSCs via activation of β-adrenergic signaling and IL-6/STAT3 pathway, thereby promoting breast carcinoma metastasis.
A search (December 9, 2024) using the following keywords: (psychological stress) AND (breast cancer) at PubMed (search engine at the United States National Library of Medicine, the NIH, Bethesda, MD) provides 3,083 results. Thus, many scientists have also linked stress to the development and progression of breast cancer.
Interestingly, breast cancer survivors consider stress a major factor for their disease. According to this report, addressing a survey published in Psychooncology, women who had survived breast cancer believe that there is a link between breast cancer and psychological stress. Or, as BBC put it, they believe stress caused their condition “than blame genetics or any other factor”.
Beta Blockers and Their Sizeable Potential in Cancer
Conceptual frameworks derived from the field of neuroendocrine-immunology at the interface between neuroscience, endocrinology and immunology hold substantial potential for the development of promising therapeutic interventions in common human diseases.
Beta blockers may represent a good example of this development and we discussed this new concept all the way back to 2011.
Why this might be the case?
Beta blockers or β-blockers are a class of medications used mostly to treat hypertension, heart failure, arrhythmias and to protect the heart from a second heart attack. Beta blockers are competitive antagonists that block β-adrenergic receptors for the endogenous catecholamines – norepinephrine (noradrenaline) and epinephrine (adrenaline).
Above in this section, we outlined some new findings that catecholamines via β-adrenergic receptor signaling are involved in tumor-related immunosuppression, and/or directly in tumor development.
But why beta blockers hold potential and what are the mechanisms? Below are listed some of them:
Immune cells and tumor cells express beta-adrenergic receptors (β-ARs).
Activation of β-adrenergic receptors mediate a selective suppression of Th1-dependent cellular immunity, and upregulation of TGF-β, IL-6, IL-8 and IL-10.
A direct effect of β-adrenergic receptors, locally, on tumor proliferation and metastasis.
The special case of the myeloid-derived suppressor cells (MDSCs), see above.
It appears that NK cells are the most ‘sensitive’ cells to the suppressive effect of stress:
In the past, NK cell activity has been used as a bona fide index of stress-induced suppression of cellular immunity.
The potent suppressive effect of catecholamines on NK cell activity is probably due to the fact that NK cells possess the highest number of β2-ARs among lymphoid cells.
Overall, the NK cells’‘supersensitivity’ to catecholamines’ effects is perhaps a major factor contributing to the suppression of cellular immunity and perhaps its complete failure in cancer (cf. Elenkov et al. 2000).
At BrainImmune Marisa Coelho et al. outlined that beta-blockers hold a promise for a novel class of antitumor agents. For example, she discussed retrospective studies showing that cancer patients taking beta-blockers survive longer due to reduced metastasis and tumor recurrence rates. Hence adjuvant use of beta-blockers in cancer chemotherapy has been actively investigated, which may open a window of opportunity for therapeutic intervention in cancer. For instance, propranolol has been shown being effective at multiple points in the metastatic cascade.
Furthermore Coelho et al. suggest that future research should include: the evaluation of β-ARs on tumor tissues as a tool to select the patients who might preferentially benefit from beta-blockers treatment; and the characterization of the beta-blockers which are more often associated with positive outcomes and which are more likely to benefit cancer patients.
At BrainImmune Stephanie McArdle also discussed that timing is everything, addressing the novel combinatorial approaches to overcome the immunosuppression in prostate cancer. Interestingly, in prostate cancer, intact sympathetic nerves are critical for tumor formation. Of note, men who take beta blockers, have been found to have a lower incidence of prostate cancer [cf. Ref. 23, her list]. Of particular interest is the fact that most of prostate cancer originate from the peripheral zone which is where most of the nerves are located [cf. Ref. 24]. Moreover, high risk cancer patients have a higher nerve density than low risk patients.
Breast cancer is the most common malignancy in women worldwide. Most breast cancer patients present with hyperactive sympathetic nervous system (SNS). Hyperactive SNS in these patients may drive and promote tumor proliferation, growth and metastasis. These features appear to be extremely amplified in triple-negative breast cancer(TNBC) patients.
Professor Manuel Martínez-Laví, an established expert in the field, discusses a new evolving concept for the presence of a sympathetic dysautonomia in fibromyalgia. His group has proposed dysautonomia as an explanation to the multiplicity of fibromyalgia symptoms including its main complaint; widespread pain, i.e. that fibromyalgia is a sympathetically maintained neuropathic pain syndrome.
Frida Kahlo: Self-Portrait with Thorn Necklace and Hummingbird (1940); Credit: Wikipedia; Mexican artist Frida Kahlo (1907-1954) is remembered for her self-portraits, pain and passion. Khalo was a self-taught artist who began painting at the age of 18 when a serious bus accident left her in a body cast to heal her spine and pelvis. From that time on, Frida suffered severe, widespread pain and profound fatigue. According to Martinez-Lavin et al., Arthritis Rheum., 2000, 43:708, Frida suffered from post-traumatic fibromyalgia. This can explain her chronic, severe, widespread pain accompanied by profound fatigue.
He concluded that the sympathetic dysautonomia is frequent in fibromyalgia patients. Such dysautonomia is characterized by relentless sympathetic hyperactivity accompanied by sympathetic hypo-reactivity to different stressors.
We also discuss an abnormal activation of microglia in fibromyalgia – microglia in patients with fibromyalgia are probably hypersensitive and overproducing tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α in response to the neurotransmitter ATP.
The inflammatory/immune component in fibromyalgia is characterized by the involvement of cytokines and chemokines such as IL-8 and IL-17. Interleukin-8 (IL-8), also known as neutrophil chemotactic factor is a chemokine known to activate neutrophils and is an important factor for the migration and infiltration of neutrophils at inflammation sites.
A 2017 study found elevated IL-8 levels in both cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) CSF and plasma fibromyalgia samples, confirming previous reports, whereas high levels of the chemokine CX3CL1 (also known as fractalkine) were monitored only in CSF samples. This may indicate the presence of both neuroinflammation and chronic systemic inflammation in fibromyalgia.
Of the 27 cytokines examined; only IL-10 was significantly decreased in the CFS group. A reduction in IL-10 may increase inflammation in the CNS as it may suggest increases in c-Jun N-terminal kinase (JNK), a known inducer of helper T cell differentiation and secretion of proinflammatory cytokines. As hippocampal related IL-10 is known to suppress JNK, reduced levels of IL-10 may have significant implications on the inflammatory processes in the CNS.
Alzheimer’s Disease and Dementia, Major Depression and Parkinson’s Disease
Stress and the risk of developing dementia and Alzheimer’s
Stress is a risk factor for amnestic mild cognitive impairment (aMCI), and the 2016 Albert Einstein College of Medicine aging study reporting high levels of perceived stress are associated with a 30% greater risk of incident aMCI. Subjects in the highest-stress quintile had an almost 2.5-times greater risk of developing aMCI, and were more likely to be female with high levels of depression.
Furthermore, Robert Wilson et al. provided new evidence that anxiety and vulnerability to stress contribute to the development of dementia. In a prospective study of more than 700 old persons the authors demonstrate that neuroticism’s association with AD risk primarily reflects two components: vulnerability to stress and anxiety.
Also, targeting neuroinflammation may be one key to slowing Alzheimer’s Disease. As discussed by Edward Tobinick a substantial and significant decreased risk of developing Alzheimer’s disease is reported in individuals with rheumatoid arthritis treated with the drug etanercept. This supplements the accumulating evidence pointing to targeting neuroinflammation, specifically excess of Tumor Necrosis Factor (TNF)-α, as a promising new direction for Alzheimer’s disease research. Of note, TNF-α has also been suggested as a possible link between age-related endocrine dyscrasia and Alzheimer’s Disease.
A Nature Medicine article is perhaps the first one to suggest interleukin (IL)-23 involvement in Alzheimer’s disease. The study reports that the microglial cells in the brains of the mouse model of Alzheimer’s disease expressed high levels of IL-12 and IL-23. This work suggests that blocking IL-12 and IL-23 in APPPS1 mouse model shows promise as an experimental therapeutic approach to Alzheimer’s disease.
Also, some complement factors such as clusterin may serve as reliable predictors of Alzheimer’s disease (AD) progression. In one of the first untargeted proteomics analyses of plasma in AD, complement factor H (FH) was found to be elevated in Alzheimer’s disease plasma compared to controls.
The brain glymphatic system
With a different perspective, Maria Teresa Ferretti and Maria Florencia Iulita reviewed the current understanding of fluid dynamics in the brain and cellular-molecular players governing the brain glymphatic system.
Graham Rook, Charles Raison and Christopher Lowry discuss new evidence relating depression to chronic inflammation and the need to consider not only the psychosocial environment, but also our changing microbiological environment.
The authors link the increasing burden of chronic inflammatory states in modern urban societies to the loss of co-evolved immunoregulation-inducing ‘Old Friends’. This ‘hygiene hypothesis’, or as they prefer to call it, the ‘Old Friends’ hypothesis, suggests that one reason for the increasing incidence of chronic inflammatory disorders in developed countries is the depletion from the urban environment of immunoregulation-inducing organisms that accompanied mammalian evolution.
The ‘old friends’ theory suggests that immune interactions with pseudocommensal mycobacterial species, gut flora members and helminthes regulate the immune system, thus explaining lower rates of atopic (Th2-mediated) and autoimmune (Th1/Th17-mediated) diseases prior to the implementation of invigorated sanitation practices in developed countries in the early 20th century.
The authors of this study found that coronary heart disease (CHD) patients with depression had higher levels of C-reactive protein (CRP) and interleukin (IL)-6 gene expression, but lower levels of cortisol and glucocorticoid receptor (GR) mRNA.
They propose a model where the level of the endogenous cortisol is insufficient to limit inflammation in CHD patients with depression, due to hypo-activity of the hypothalamus–pituitary–adrenal axis and GR resistance. Thus, chronic inflammation in patients with CHD may contribute to the development of depression, which in turn leads to further activation of inflammatory processes as reflected in joint elevation in IL-6 expression and CRP.
The role of Oxytocin
We discuss new evidence for a deficit of oxytocin in women with depression, including patients with psychotic major depression (PMD). This study reports that plasma oxytocin levels were decreased in depressed females. As depression is much more common in women, the study may also help explain the female preponderance of depression.
Another study by Karen Parker et al. links low levels of oxytocin with anxiety in children. In this study both plasma and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) oxytocin concentrations significantly and negatively predict trait anxiety in children. This supports the hypothesis of an imbalance of the endogenous brain oxytocin system in the etiology of anxiety disorders.
The role of Interleukin-6 (IL-6)
A study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA is perhaps the first to demonstrate that the magnitude of peripheral interleukin (IL)-6 responses preceding stress challenge may confer inter-individual differences in susceptibility or resilience to a subsequent social stressor.
They show that in healthy male volunteers the administration of low-dose endotoxin induced a robust increase of IL-6 in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). They observed a strong association between the endotoxin-induced increase of IL-6 in the CSF and the severity of mood impairment. These findings suggest that the appearance of depressive symptoms in inflammatory conditions might be primarily linked to an increase in central IL-6 concentration, identifying IL-6 as a potential therapeutic target in mood disorders.
These data reinforce the concept that peripheral immunity is involved in the pathophysiology of cognitive decline in PD. The dysregulation of the T regulatory compartment may impair the anti-inflammatory functions of these cells, hence contributing to the perpetuation of an inflamed central environment resulting in worsening of neurodegeneration. Thus, the peripheral immune system represents a suitable therapeutic target in PD.
The authors point out that the emerging role of peripheral immunity and of the gut microbiota in the pathogenesis and progression of PD may provide unprecedented opportunities for the development of novel disease-modifying therapeutics. Would the contribution of (auto)immune mechanisms in PD be confirmed, candidate drugs for PD could include drugs already validated for diseases such as psoriasis, rheumatoid arthritis and inflammatory bowel disease, as well as less conventional approaches for the modulation of immunity.
If you like our mission and share our values – take a moment and visit our Donate/Support page – please consider making a one-time donation via the PayPal option there.